What Are the Main Limitations of the Chinese Law System in Its Treatment of Criminal Minors, and How Could These Be Improved?
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.61173/er69fs11Keywords:
Juvenile delinquency, criminal responsibility age, cognitive ability assessment, corrective education, “Malice Supplies the Age” doctrine, Chinese criminal lawAbstract
The rising rate of juvenile delinquency in China, particularly among minors under 14, has exposed significant limitations in the existing legal framework. This dissertation aims to identify the main deficiencies in the Chinese legal system concerning the treatment of criminal minors and to propose feasible improvements. Employing secondary research, this study analyzes official judicial data, legal provisions (including the 2020 Criminal Law Amendment (XI) and the 2021 Criminal Law Amendment (XI)), and recent case studies, such as the Handan murder case and the Qingyuan sexual assault case. A comparative legal analysis is conducted with Germany's welfare‑oriented juvenile system and the United Kingdom’s “Malice Supplies the Age” doctrine. The findings reveal three primary limitations: an incomplete system for assessing juvenile delinquents’ cognitive ability, an overly narrow scope and high threshold for criminal responsibility (limited to intentional homicide and injury for ages 12–14), and an underdeveloped system of special correctional education. The dissertation concludes that improvements require establishing a multi‑dimensional evaluation system for cognitive capacity, lowering the criminal responsibility threshold to include other heinous crimes such as rape and robbery, and enhancing the professionalism and resources allocated to corrective education. These reforms aim to balance the protection of minors’ rights with the safeguarding of social interests.
References
[1] Gao, Q. (2012) Legal basis. China, Tsinghua University Press. http://tup.tsinghua.edu.cn/bookscenter/book_08971902.html
[2] The Supreme People's Procuratorate of the People's Republic of China. (2024) White Paper on Juvenile Procuratorial Work.
[3] Standing Committee of the National People's Congress.
[2021] President's Order No. 66. Criminal Law Amendment (XI), effective 2021. China, Standing Committee of the National People's Congress.
[4] Standing Committee of the National People's Congress. (2020). Standing Committee of the National People's Congress.
[5] Yu, H. & Yin, M. (2024). Criminal Regulation of Juvenile Delinquency by Underage Offenders: From the Perspective of the 'Malice Supplies the Age' Doctrine. Journal Henan University of Science and Technology(Social Science).42(6), 55-61. https://kns.cnki.net/kcms2/article/abstract?v=Ut-mckhA- RsQDVfL4P-DOxuVS8nzxkjmIsJChMpx6For-mYip4qs3 OYsAbibaxE9cUTvh6L9BbPzPW3sszW6ul8O7j-_ceG5_ J4Zb3NwY61AJOQG-kk3Le0Sqo9H0Ty4p4Kz7djmOB29jiJh6 fRstqmCax70W1dCxFqUR5046WFWZHjrCBLOWQ==&unipl atform=NZKPT&language=CHS
[6] Yang, H. & Deng, Y. (2025). The Minimum Age of Criminal Responsibility System: Challenges and Countermeasures in Addressing the Trend of Younger Offenders.Nan Fang Lun Kan,
[3] , 71-76. h t t p s : / / k n s . c n k i . n e t / k c m s 2 / a r t i c l e / abstract?v=hx6LgM6qJjvYqIMl15-TUSU1aDY3bJH2hQ2sz XDZ5iL4FcEfIFfINudnWCEyhkpyDZ52J-J800xLVO4TOu-- WYK6gWOyV39-lUnNp4BLPAX6J4xVN58LilxuZd2m1fu3aK bAwIjbBTPTCP-IyVPG7fGFXdlYF-BybJiAo1NWGAUWyn_ edAVNhA==&uniplatform=NZKPT&language=CHS
[7] Huang, D. & Ma, L. (2025) Practical Challenges and Countermeasures in Preventing Juvenile Delinquency Among Very Young Offenders. Journal of Henan Police College. 34(1), 24-35. https://kns.cnki.net/kcms2/article/abstract?v=Ut-mckhA- RuuYRCtMcXTVeCAu7cnIJG7-yKavMYULPWn4RC9NoufD YHjplTlBbyrkLIh_ox52zmfuqsxuEZ2U7axuJu8sXs1w4bfKltd_ aJqHPUe8EFeVSgYeZtj5y9vWFAZkEyItCQvXZ9ukfbU8L8m ntJYu7_FsYprud5tB76VaBlxQ_qQng==&uniplatform=NZKPT &language=CHS
[8] Wang, P. & Zhang, X. (2025). Optimization of the Graded Intervention System for Juvenile Offenders: A Perspective Based on Deliberative Legal Socialization. Henan Social Sciences. 33(4), 40-51. h t t p s : / / k n s . c n k i . n e t / k c m s 2 / a r t i c l e / a b s t r a c t ? v = i L v e m b e b N j w 2 G F e I A _ g O 5 _ n 4 4 c V- l 3 2 d M K A I w p - f m q U 2 K q h J M s G e Q C r 0 r k 7 _ o44FWOuIyLA10UMJX9fHaPJPDcravfW-9ahEoAD Dean&Francis ISSN 2959-6149 pKrMZ9GT5pSHCp1oIF55tCNPlpHeW431gCD1E_ XCYxAkYr8uRr87ELLeI2dlemfK_GRWn-oTHI10RV2Jz7A== &uniplatform=NZKPT&language=CHS
[9] Zhang, T. (2024). The Social Law Approach to Juvenile Crime Prevention in Germany and Its Lessons for China.Chinese Journal of Criminal Law. 66(4), 161-176. https://kns.cnki.net/kcms2/article/abstract?v=Ut-mckhA-Rv1ItT CHdurU9BJ9b_47tjITz2qNn2STOzSwxivXII7JmK2zl4D3I3bL 6XVH-VXBkRfmJQCr_BUCgVoklFoAQnUKj1ZjocT88mJoqF ROrCfXSX3kbObkD2kFbeKSzs0PW5ONK1fnjs61-NB1ZRS_ ttVT0XIMsm4LSJC-WQjTQUAJQ==&uniplatform=NZKPT&l anguage=CHS
[10] Zheng, H. (2025). On the Prevention Mechanism of Juvenile Delinquency in China. Western Academic Journal. 27(4), 96-99. h t t p s : / / k n s . c n k i . n e t / k c m s 2 / a r t i c l e / a b s t r a c t ? v = F qAfUZ3F7bYdNfv7_KOxkpOkJtNmG6FTHVpOnLczTem x8Fen5Pvg1qRAlvOpzdvt5X414ULWLEDlNtKK3zg8nA5 JXtM4-HOEjpr9Paz2BuW3FmdXFMUSCJPYVLaGS4wj_ fOg1sSgja2fja1na2FfrP-WE_4_3A15MqDAOI5zrEkFJGbXM_ ySUA==&uniplatform=NZKPT&language=CHS
[11] Standing Committee of the National People's Congress.
[2020] President's Order No. 57: Law of the People's Republic of China on the Protection of Minors. China.
[12] Standing Committee of the National People's Congress.
[2018] President's Order No. 10: Criminal Procedure Law of the People's Republic of China. China, Standing Committee of the National People's Congress.
[13] Zeng, S. & Hua, L. (2024). Research on the Current Situation and Prevention of Juvenile Delinquency: A Case Study Based on Juvenile Crime Cases Handled by H Procuratorate in Recent Three Years. Juvenile Delinquency Prevention Research. 61(5), 51-57. https://kns.cnki.net/kcms2/article/abstract?v=hx6LgM6qJjtDpyS WnlGoJ6pKCfmqOME08zi7eHNXLZNALQpG-RyhPWJpr9lh 4T5siIoZUv2iYoemZFp2Qp3KBx3ZOJnzVToxP_xchTYPfERz uOx7Fq1KlakQScyyEiUdHnJOy0IwYq03rTT7xs32eTkHQfemI 1wx9cd11WTH4Dx1Dg8z2hK8KQ==&uniplatform=NZKPT&l anguage=CHS
[14] The Supreme People's Procuratorate of the People's Republic of China. (2024) First-Trial Verdict in Case of Junior High School Student Murder in Handan, Hebei. Retrieved June 29, 2025, from https://www.spp.gov.cn/zdgz/202412/ t20241230_678121.shtml
[15] German Federal Parliament, the Bundestag. (2023) BGBl. I S. 1084, Juvenile Court Act. Germany.
[16] Central Broadcasting Network. (2024) In Yangshan, Guangdong Province, an 8-year-old girl was sexually assaulted by a 13-year-old boy. Retrieved August 27, 2025, from https://www.cnr.cn/gd/guangdongyaowen/20240320/ t20240320_526633185.shtml
[17] Huang, D. (2025) Analysis of the Typification of Juvenile Delinquency and Research on Prevention Paths in Criminal Situations. New Generation. 7(1), 35-44. https://kns.cnki.net/kcms2/article/abstract?v=J4uTGPHNJK2jot kJMn4YEg91-WHPUyKnBuqOQs7JB02TNNROmAL5eqaskI CwSn0DtOm6NAcCABdxBflpuLGkHsiAggDjRcIh-wKRKAS cwnD2lDWUKltRgl9IqBf8jjrX4MZc7yj1ZDBk2tRyepcUEcXo vTFOnL5aat4ykhsFf6lm6LE936zcuw==&uniplatform=NZKPT &language=CHS
[18] Wang, Z. (2024). The basic logic and system construction of juvenile delinquency prevention and governance. Chinese Rule of Law. 22(12), 102-107. h t t p s : / / k n s . c n k i . n e t / k c m s 2 / a r t i c l e / a b s t r a ct?v=J4uTGPHNJK0ew9gYAsUVA7-1WL9orDKK vxZVmxp9p315KJHBNPL0TbOz-wwm_fJ9BwLDChWZC_fe QQMHeqPNWp5jW4UGE6VK6qTbrNjha19yQqK5IHoUFXT wap_3GUFCkI5HNd-8l19OVPJjrgIu-G2_rP-HyxwxocXvlxDFn Og70nchlhFmWg==&uniplatform=NZKPT&language=CHS
[19] Giedd, J. N. , Blumenthal, J. , Jeffries, N. O. , Castellanos, F. X. , Liu, H. , Zijdenbos, A. , et al. ( 1999 ) Brain development during childhood and adolescence: A longitudinal MＲI study. Nature Neuroscience. 2, 861 － 863. https://www.nature.com/ articles/nn0999_861
[20] Bunge, S. A. , & Wright, S. B. ( 2007) Neurodevelopmental changes in working memory and cognitive control. Current opinion in neurobiology. 17( 2), 243 － 250. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/ S0959438807000362
[21] Huang, C. (2025) Imbalance and Correction: Education and Punishment for Juvenile Delinquency. Journal of Jincheng Polytechnic. 18(1), 92-96. https://kns.cnki.net/kcms2/article/abstract?v=J4uTG PHNJK0BO-RhfkLvhkgJCPbtUwi2bVL5C4458kLhTNSFVMx fHcHwhl9wgLiXPmzgX999W6ZMsnHV9pZwPr82dsiGn2f9fN pLLtnLUIKFr7bTZoMEyFHB0VP3r1nWRhBRYKQ9g4JzdLR UplNPjFmlXeU4TCKU2LJ-60OgxPHf0AxkKqfvfQ==&uniplat form=NZKPT&language=CHS
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 by the authors.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
