Do we need to treat psychopathy like psychiatry in criminal law?
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.61173/0edygh18Keywords:
criminal law, psychiatry, psychopathy, legal systemAbstract
This manuscript reviews the differences between psychiatry and psychopathy, as well as why modern laws have different punishments for psychiatric patients compared to normal people and then expresses the rationality of differentiating punishments for psychopaths in the legal system under contemporary research on the brain and genes, and discusses the serious consequences this behavior may bring.
References
serious consequences of such an expansion. (2008). The differences between psychiatry and psychopathy are [2] Blair, R. J. R., Mitchell, D. G. V. & Blair, K. S. The not always clear - cut. Psychopathy, often considered a Psychopath: Emotion and the Brain (Blackwell, 2005). personality disorder, has distinct characteristics such as [3] American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and Statistical lack of empathy, superficial charm, impulsivity, manip- Manual of Mental Disorders: DSM-5 5th edn (American ulative behavior, and disregard for laws and rules. The Psychiatric Association, 2013). development of psychopathy is influenced by both genetic [4] Kim S J ,Ilaria S ,Hundal J , et al. Coffin-Lowry Syndrome: A and environmental factors. The insanity defence, which Case of Clinical Convergence for Psychology, Neuropsychology, has a long - standing history, is based on the principle Psychiatry, Genetics, and Neurology. [J]. Journal of child
of protecting individuals with mental illnesses who lack neurology, 2025, 8830738241308605. criminal responsibility or have limited criminal responsi- [5] Felice F Carabellese, Lia Parente. The Italian general bility. However, the application of the insanity defence to psychiatry and forensic psychiatry treatment model: a unique
psychopaths is a matter of debate.New perspectives from story.[J]. CNS spectrums, 2025, 1-5. forensic psychiatry, such as Damasio’s body symbol the- [6] Godman M ,Jefferson A . On Blaming and Punishing
ory and the findings from neuroimaging studies, suggest Psychopaths [J]. Criminal Law and Philosophy, 2017, 11 (1): that psychopaths may have impaired moral knowledge ac- 127-142. quisition and recognition and control abilities. These find- [7] Jorde P L ,Petter L ,Kjersti N , et al. Are symptoms assessed ings provide support for the idea of imposing lenient pun- differently for schizophrenia and other psychoses in legal ishment on psychopaths. Functional magnetic resonance insanity evaluations of violent crimes? [J]. BMC psychiatry,
imaging (fMRI) technology has also revealed abnormal 2023, 23 (1): 487-487.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 by the authors.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
